Open Letter to Charlotte Talks Host (WFAE)

On Language, Race and Media Responsibility

Dear Charlotte Talks Team,

As a regular listener and engaged member of the Charlotte community, I appreciate the platform Charlotte Talks provides for thoughtful civic dialogue. I’m writing about the recent panel discussion of Councilwoman Tiawana Brown—specifically, the use of the phrase "the race card” and the conversation around media accountability.

In my recent, Open Letter to Charlotte City Leaders I publicly criticized Ms. Brown because I believe invoking race—or blaming the media—should not deflect from legitimate public inquiry or serious allegations. Accountability in public office is essential, and I believe everyone should be held—regardless of background—to the same standard of responsibility and transparency.

I found it particularly troubling that the phrase “playing the race card” was used so casually—especially on an all-white panel. In reality, privilege means holding virtually the entire deck, not a single card; and yet, ironically, no one ever accuses white people of “playing the race card.” This choice of language risks reinforcing harmful stereotypes about an entire community rather than addressing one individual, and it minimizes the lived experiences of those who face genuine racism every day.

I also noted your frustration with public figures blaming the media. While media scapegoating is a real phenomenon, the phrase “race card” itself was created and popularized as a tool for those in positions of power to delegitimize marginalized voices—something Black Americans have never been afforded the luxury of doing. Raising concerns about racism has, for many, carried grave risks from public shaming to violence including lynching. This is precisely why I immediately criticized Ms. Brown’s suggestion that her race was being used to deflect from her indictment.

Of course, robust debate requires linguistic freedom. My point is simply that certain terms carry serious historical weight that demands careful consideration—especially on public radio.

Public media has a unique responsibility to model thoughtful, inclusive discourse. I hope future discussions of race and governance will reflect greater sensitivity, nuance, and a range of perspectives.

Thank you for considering this feedback in the spirit of constructive engagement and my belief in the power of public media to elevate our community’s conversations.

Founder | The Citizens’ Project 2025
Restoring Democracy Through Citizen Leadership

Creator | Letter and Luxe
CNN Hero | Writer | Builder of Beautiful Things

📩 robin@robinemmons.com
🌐 The Margins and The Mirror
📷 Instagram: @robinwrites2025